The Premier League has long been known for its flair, drama, and intense competitiveness. While strikers and attacking midfielders often dominate headlines with their goal-scoring feats, some defenders have defied expectations by consistently finding the back of the net. These rare talents combine their primary defensive duties with an uncanny ability to contribute goals, often in the most crucial moments. This article by Wintips explores the 10 top scoring defenders in Premier League history.
The 10 top scoring defenders in Premier League history
Here’s a closer look at the 10 top scoring defenders in Premier League history, with some surprising names on the list.
10. Julian Dicks – 24 goals
Julian Dicks was a rugged and no-nonsense left-back who earned his reputation at West Ham United and had a brief spell at Liverpool. Known for his fierce tackling and powerful left foot, Dicks was also one of the most reliable penalty-takers of his era. Most of his 24 goals in the Premier League came from the spot, underlining his calmness and precision from 12 yards.
His best season came in 1995/96 when he scored 10 goals in 34 games- an incredible tally for a full-back. Dicks’ unique blend of aggression and technical ability made him a cult hero, particularly among West Ham supporters.
9. William Gallas – 25 goals
William Gallas made headlines not just for his solid defending but also for the rare feat of playing for three of London’s biggest clubs- Chelsea, Arsenal, and Tottenham Hotspur. A versatile player capable of featuring as a center-back or full-back, Gallas scored 25 Premier League goals over his career.
During his time at Chelsea, Gallas became known for scoring crucial goals in tight matches, often popping up unexpectedly in the opponent’s box. His ability to time his runs and find space made him a valuable offensive asset during set pieces. Though not a prolific scorer by attacking standards, Gallas' tally remains impressive for a defender.
8. Steve Watson – 26 goals
Steve Watson was a dependable utility player who represented Newcastle United, Aston Villa, Everton, and West Bromwich Albion. Comfortable playing anywhere across the backline and even in midfield, Watson accumulated 26 goals during his Premier League career.
Which betting site has the highest odds? Find out now to get the best betting options.
He enjoyed two standout seasons with Everton in 2002/03 and 2003/04, scoring five goals in each and even netting a rare hat-trick- a rare feat for a defender. While his role occasionally saw him push into midfield, his consistent ability to score from various positions justifies his inclusion in this elite list.
7. Marcos Alonso – 26 goals
Marcos Alonso brought a modern touch to goal-scoring from the back. A specialist in free kicks and long-range shots, the Spanish left-back made a name for himself at Chelsea, where he scored 26 Premier League goals.
His standout season came in 2017/18 when he found the net seven times in 33 games. Alonso's attacking instincts, coupled with his skill from dead-ball situations, often saw him deployed in more advanced roles. Even during his stints with Bolton Wanderers and Sunderland, Alonso hinted at his goal-scoring potential, but it was at Chelsea where he truly flourished.
6. Gary Cahill – 28 goals
Gary Cahill's imposing presence in the air and his knack for timing his runs into the box made him a constant threat during corners and free kicks. Over his career, which included spells at Aston Villa, Bolton Wanderers, Chelsea, and Crystal Palace, the former England international scored 28 Premier League goals.
Cahill was a mainstay in Chelsea’s defense during one of the club's most successful eras. He won multiple Premier League titles, and his contribution wasn't just limited to defending. His goals, often headers from set pieces, frequently helped his team secure vital points.
5. Ian Harte – 28 goals
A dead-ball specialist, Ian Harte made his mark at Leeds United, where he scored all 28 of his Premier League goals. Harte’s left foot was a weapon, especially from free kicks and long-range efforts. His precision and vision allowed him to produce goals that many attacking midfielders would be proud of.
Though primarily a left-back, Harte often took set-piece responsibilities, which boosted his goal tally. His ability to whip the ball into the net from impossible angles added an extra dimension to Leeds United’s attack during the late 1990s and early 2000s.
4. Leighton Baines – 32 goals
Leighton Baines was not just one of the most consistent left-backs in Premier League history; he was also among its most prolific. Splitting his career between Wigan Athletic and Everton, Baines tallied 32 goals in the top flight.
Much like Ian Harte, Baines was a set-piece maestro. His ability to convert penalties and free kicks made him an invaluable asset. Moreover, his attacking runs, vision, and accurate crossing earned him countless assists to go alongside his goal tally. For years, Baines was Everton’s primary penalty-taker, often coolly dispatching efforts into the corners with surgical precision.
3. Ian Marshall – 33 goals
Ian Marshall may be the most surprising name on this list. Known more for his rugged playing style than finesse, Marshall managed to net 33 goals in just 157 Premier League appearances. He played for clubs such as Oldham Athletic, Ipswich Town, Leicester City, and Bolton Wanderers.
Though he started his career as a center-back, Marshall was occasionally deployed as a striker due to his natural goal-scoring instincts. This versatility allowed him to become one of the most efficient scoring defenders in Premier League history. Whether it was with his head, from the spot, or inside the box, Marshall had a striker’s instinct in a defender’s body.
2. David Unsworth – 38 goals
David Unsworth was a solid and reliable defender who spent the majority of his career at Everton. Known for his leadership and tactical intelligence, Unsworth also made his name as a reliable penalty taker. Out of his 38 Premier League goals, a significant number came from the penalty spot.
His best scoring period came between 1999 and 2001, when he netted 11 goals over two seasons. Unsworth's final Premier League goal was a memorable one, as he converted a penalty to help Wigan avoid relegation in 2007. That moment encapsulated his career: dependable, clutch, and always calm under pressure.
1. John Terry – 41 goals
Topping the list is none other than Chelsea legend John Terry. Widely regarded as one of the best center-backs of his generation, Terry combined defensive steel with an impressive goal-scoring record, netting 41 goals in the Premier League.
Most of Terry’s goals came from headers during set pieces. His physical presence and timing made him a nightmare for opposition defenders during corners. Terry scored six goals in both the 2010/11 and 2011/12 seasons- an incredible achievement for a central defender.
His leadership qualities were unmatched, and he often led by example, not just by organizing the defense but by scoring in crucial moments. Terry’s goal-scoring ability set a new benchmark for what was expected of modern center-backs.
In summary
While the Premier League will always celebrate its elite forwards and midfield magicians, the contributions of top scoring defenders in Premier League should not go unnoticed. They brought versatility, bravery, and technical ability to their roles, and in doing so, they etched their names into the league’s rich history. As football continues to evolve, perhaps the next generation of defenders will not only break up play but break records too. And when they do, they’ll be following in the footsteps of these Premier League legends.
Read more: Top 6 worst open goal misses that left fans in disbelief.
